Book Review | We Were Liars by E. Lockhart

we-were-liars-book-review-paiges-pagesTITLE: We Were Liars
AUTHOR: E. Lockhart
PUBLISHER: Allen & Unwin
RELEASE DATE: May 13, 2014
GENRE: Young Adult Fiction

We Were Liars has a reputation for dividing readers – whether you love it or hate it, everyone seems to have a strong opinion about this book.  While I hoped to be blown away, I didn’t connect with the characters.  While some aspects of the story resonated with me, overall I wasn’t impacted as much as I expected and hoped to be.

Every summer, the Sinclairs live it up on their private island.  15-year-old Cadence and her cousins – the “Liars” – spend the summer making mischief.  However, an unexplained accident that results in Cadence’s amnesia and crippling migraines forces her to question the Sinclair’s paradise.  

Welcome to the beautiful Sinclair family.  No one is a criminal.  No one is an addict.  No one is a failure.  The Sinclairs are athletic, tall, and handsome.  We are old-money Democrats.  Our smiles are wide, our chins are square, and our tennis serves aggressive – page 1

We see the events of We Were Liars through Cadence’s eyes.  Her voice is unique, ironically romantic to show how tragic her family’s delusions of grandeur truly are.  Cadence is an unreliable narrator – we learn the events leading up to her memory loss through time-hopping and guesses.  Her voice also uses a lot of repetition and surreal imagery.  While some readers will enjoy this style, I found it jarring.

My full name is Cadence Sinclair Eastman … It is true I suffer migraines since my accident.  It is true I do not suffer fools.  I like a twist of meaning.  You see?  Suffer migraines.  Do not suffer fools.  The word means almost the same as it did in the previous sentence, but not quite.  Suffer.  You could say it means endure, but that’s not exactly right – page 4

Cadence’s story centres on her relationships with her fellow Liars – cousins Mirren and Johnny, and step-cousin Gat.  I didn’t empathise with any of them – not even Gat whom Cadence views through rose-tinted glasses.  That said, the Sinclairs are purposely dislikable.  Their attitude of entitlement and constant fighting reveals the ugliness of their hearts.  As a result, I often felt like I was watching an over-acted theatre performance.  I assume this alienation is deliberate, but it didn’t resonate with me at all.

The entire plot leads up to a shocking twist.  Exactly as the book’s title suggests, every nook and cranny of the story is littered with lies that amount to one huge deception.  Although I didn’t feel connected to the characters, the twist was confronting enough to shock me.

I understand why readers disagree over We Were Liars – different aspects of the story and the character’s struggles will touch many different chords.  It has the power to provoke self-reflection and discussion.  I can see the merit in this story even if it wasn’t for me.  

8 thoughts on “Book Review | We Were Liars by E. Lockhart

  1. cw @ readthinkponder says:

    Great review Paige! I’ve been very torn about reading this book because of its mixed reception. (I remember someone calling it, ‘we were tedious’? 😂
    Like most of Nolan’s movies, I don’t like books with the *massive* twist at the end which make you think ‘omg, I have to rethink the whole book now!!!’ I think I’m going to trust your review here and give this book a pass.
    Thank you for the review!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Paige @ Paige's Pages says:

      Thank you CW! Good point, I’m not usually one for massive twists either. We Were Liars crawled towards a glaringly obvious twist, and I feel like my biggest point of engagement was trying to guess it! (Totally distanced from the actual story and not even caring at this point). If twists aren’t up your alley, I’d give it a miss. But honestly, so many readers disagree with me, it might be the best book ever for someone else.


  2. Georgiana Darcy says:

    Damn it! I was so excited to read you review hoping you liked the book. I definitely fell in love with We Were Liars from the very first page, so it’s unfortunate that you did not click with it. I can definitely see where you are coming from, and your points are absolutely justified. It’s hard to judge the novel since, in my opinion, it’s pretty unusual. The writing, the characters, the idea. Everything is a little off, and it’s true, you either love it or hate it.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Georgiana Darcy Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s